Reading the result honestly
Panels rarely award either side’s opening number. Line items backed by measurements, photos and local pricing usually hold; padding usually falls. That’s why the estimator asks where the award might land rather than assuming you win everything. Try three scenarios — 30%, 55% and 80% — and look at the spread.
The break-even landing point is the share of the gap the panel must award just to cover your appraisal costs. If it’s above about 50%, your file needs to be very strong. If it’s under 20%, appraisal is probably worth a serious conversation.
Fee structures you may see
- Flat fee: a set price agreed in writing up front.
- Percentage of the increase: paid only on money above the carrier’s number.
- Hourly: common for umpires and for large commercial losses.
Whichever arrangement you choose, get it in writing before work starts. Each side normally pays its own appraiser and splits the umpire’s fee.
What this tool leaves out
It sizes the dispute at replacement cost. Deductibles, depreciation timing and sub-limits change what reaches your bank account — use the holdback recovery calculator and the named-storm deductible calculator for those.
About this calculator
Is the projected award a prediction?
No. It is a planning scenario based on the numbers you enter. Real awards depend on documentation, policy wording and the panel.
How big should the gap be before I consider appraisal?
As a rough rule of thumb, gaps under about 10% of the carrier’s estimate or a few thousand dollars are often better handled with a documented supplement request.
Are my numbers saved?
No. The estimator runs entirely in your browser and nothing is stored or sent.
