MississippiInsurance Appraiser (844) 537-1427

Appraisal service

A Neutral Umpire When Two Appraisers Can’t Agree

When the appraisers named by each side reach a stalemate on some items, the umpire breaks the tie. That role only works if the umpire is genuinely independent of both parties.

  • RoleNeutral third appraiser
  • Chosen byAppraisers or a court
  • ConditionNo ties to either side

The umpire’s job in a Mississippi appraisal

Under a typical appraisal clause, each side names its own appraiser. The two appraisers try to agree on the amount of loss. Where they can’t, they submit their differences to an umpire. An award signed by any two of the three — the two appraisers, or one appraiser and the umpire — sets the amount of loss.

The umpire doesn’t represent anyone. The umpire’s job is to understand both estimates, look at the property, and decide the disputed items fairly. In practice, appraisers often agree on most of the estimate, and the umpire focuses on the items still open.

Umpires come into a file in two ways. Sometimes the appraisers pick one at the start, before any disagreement, so the umpire is ready if needed. Other times the appraisers work for weeks, narrow their differences and only then bring in an umpire for the handful of items still open. Either approach works; what matters is that the choice is made by agreement or by a court, not by one side alone.

How an umpire gets chosen

Most policies tell the two appraisers to select an umpire together, often within 15 days of their own appointment. If they can’t agree, many clauses let either party ask a court of record to appoint one. Each side typically shares the umpire’s fee equally.

A few practical points:

  • Appraisers usually exchange a short list of candidates and strike names until they find one both accept.
  • Candidates should disclose any relationships with the parties, the carrier, the appraisers or their firms before accepting.
  • If a court appoints the umpire, the process and timing follow that court’s procedure; a Mississippi attorney can explain it.
  • The umpire’s fee arrangement should be set in writing before work starts.
When we decline

We serve as umpire only when we’re neutral to both sides. If we’ve worked for the policyholder, have a relationship with the carrier that could reasonably raise questions, or have an interest in the outcome, we’ll say so and step aside.

Disclosure before acceptance

Independence is the umpire’s whole value. Before accepting, we check for conflicts and disclose anything that might reasonably bear on neutrality, so both appraisers can decide with full information. If something comes up later, we disclose it then. A clear record protects the award from challenges based on bias.

How we run an umpire file

Submissions

We ask each appraiser for their estimate, a list of items in dispute and a short explanation of their position. Photos, measurements and supporting documents help.

Inspection

We usually inspect the property, ideally with both appraisers present, to see the disputed areas for ourselves.

Decision

We decide the open items, often line by line, and work toward an award that at least one appraiser will sign with us. Where an item turns on a technical question — whether shingles can be repaired, how far smoke migrated, how long a reasonable repair should take — we may ask both appraisers for more support or review manufacturer guidance before deciding. The award states the amount of loss, usually split into replacement cost and actual cash value where the policy calls for it.

Limits of the umpire’s role

An umpire, like the appraisers, decides the amount of loss. Coverage questions, exclusions, causation disputes such as wind versus flood, and bad-faith claims stay outside appraisal. We’re not a law firm, and we don’t give legal advice to either side. For the full picture of how appraisal moves from demand to award, see the appraisal roadmap. If you need an appraiser on your side instead, see appraisal demand representation. To ask about umpire availability, talk to an appraiser.

Available across Mississippi

Neutral Umpire Services is available statewide. Inspections are scheduled around your timeline in places such as Oxford, Pascagoula, Vicksburg, Columbus.

Neutral Umpire Services questions

Can one side choose the umpire alone?

Generally no. The two appraisers choose together, and if they can’t agree, many clauses let either side ask a court of record to appoint one.

Who pays the umpire in a Mississippi appraisal?

Most clauses split the umpire’s fee equally between the policyholder and the carrier. Check your policy for its specific wording.

Can the umpire decide coverage issues?

No. The umpire, like the appraisers, decides the amount of loss; coverage and legal questions stay outside the appraisal.

Related services

Not sure the carrier’s number is right?

Send the estimate and a few photos. We’ll review it and tell you what we see — no obligation.

Call now Free claim review